Warning: This is long. And I use the lyrics to Dar Williams’ February completely shamelessly, to talk about the ex-ex-ex, who I dumped 3 years ago today.
I threw your keys in the water, I looked back,
Theyd frozen halfway down in the ice.
They froze up so quickly, the keys and their owners,
Even after the anger, it all turned silent, and
The everyday turned solitary,
So we came to February.
Ryan and I broke up in February. February 15, 2004, a little before midnight, thus making me the bitch who dumped her boyfriend on his 21st birthday, to be exact.
I was free. After years of emotional abuse and manipulation and never being allowed to be right about anything.
After years of silent understandings, familiar car rides, and cuddling. I have yet to equal that level of commitment, comfort, etc in a relationship, and sometimes I fear I never will. Right afterwards, falling in to a rebound fling with a longterm crush, I was so used to that level of comfort that I automatically tried to capture it. It was disasterous.
I used to love Ryan with every ounce of my being. But I had to get out.
First we forgot where wed planted those bulbs last year,
Then we forgot that wed planted at all,
Then we forgot what plants are altogether,
and I blamed you for my freezing and forgetting and
The nights were long and cold and scary,
Can we live through February?
In the weeks leading up to the break-up, the suffocation I had felt for months – and perhaps years – must have been growing, but I don’t remember how that felt. Since reconnecting with Ryan, I’ve forgotten how bad The Bad felt. In the past eight months had, until recently, only reminded me of the good we had. We were good together once. That makes me sad; that we were so, so good, and became so horrible. And with our reconciliation I kept thinking about how we could have done things differently, and what I could have done, and really, that was an unhealthy attitude. We both contributed to the destruction.
I blamed him for so many of my insecurities and anxities and issues, and while he definitely played a role in creating and perpetuating many of them, I no longer knew how much was him and how much was me. Is anyone totally secure during the ages of 16-20?
You know I think Christmas was a long red glare,
Shot up like a warning, we gave presents without cards,
And then the snow,
And then the snow came, we were always out shoveling,
And wed drop to sleep exhausted,
Then wed wake up, and its snowing.
We literally did give presents without cards that Christmas. Impersonal gifts. He gave my lacy, pink lingerie, which I am totally not the type for, and yet totally am the type for. (What gave me laughs a few weeks after the break-up, when we did an exchange of belongings, he demanded that back, as I wasn’t to wear it with anyone else. I was in shock and just gave it back, because dude, it was just NOT me, but Xina and I did get a good laugh about what he was going to do with it)
And that was also the semester that it snowed a lot. And it was the semester that we spent every weekend curled up together and comfortable. We felt very much serious and long-term, and forever.
I did love him. A lot, I don’t want to minimize that. If I hadn’t loved him so much, this wouldn’t be a big deal.
And February was so long that it lasted into March
And found us walking a path alone together..
And then I went to Model EU. And I met someone, who understood what it was like when ‘college just isn’t the best four years of your life’ and he understood WHY that was so hard to get through. Yeah, I hooked up with him. Yeah, I cheated on my boyfriend. No, I’m no sorry for that. That day changed me life. I think it was that experience that made me realize I HAD to leave Ryan. I wish I could explain how suffocated I felt .Maybe that would make me seem less cruel. I suck.
You stopped and pointed and you said, “That’s a crocus.”
And I said “what’s a crocus”; and you said, “it’s a flower”
I tried to remember, but I said “What’s a flower?”
You said “I still love you”
He showed up at Hickory A two nights after the break-up. He wanted to talk. He begged me for just ten minutes. I wouldn’t give it to him. I shot him down. I made him leave. I realize, in retrospect, if he had done that to me, I would have shattered. At least when he broke up with me back in high school, he didn’t cut me off like that, althought maybe he should have.
“When you left me I finally got my life back,” he spat at me in a fight a few weeks ago. And though I feel the same, that I got my life back when we broke up, I still see a life I had with him and I can’t hate it anymore. It was over four years of my life, and to hate it would be to hate who I am right now. I can’t regret it, because what’s the fucking point anymore? Yes, we should have broken up before college, but we didn’t and it isn’t as if we didn’t have good mixed in with tthe bad. So I can’t reject years of my life as a mistake; I won’t.
But he does, and part of him will always hate me, and that hurts. And it hurts that he goes out of his way to say things that will hurt me. I don’t do that to him. Because it is not worth it to bring that all into question, especially after we spent the whole summer hashing this stuff out. But he doesnt’ feel that way. I’m still the villian. The bitch.
I guess, given my behavior, that I’d hate me too. And maybe I should hate him. Maybe that was better.
The leaves were turning as we drove to the hardware store,
My new lover made me keys to the house,
It was so easy for me to do, because at the time I had HeWhoShallNotBeNamed, who I’d had a crush on FOREVER, and its so pathetic that that was what gave me the guts to dump Ryan. (the only way to divorce darling, is through another man) He wound up hurting me eventually and karma wise I’m sure I deserved everything I got.
And when we got home, well we just started chopping wood,
Because you never know how next year will be,
And well gather all our arms can carry,
I have lost to February.
So every February 15th, I’m going to be reminded about how I dumped the potential love of my life — on his birthday — and walked away, throwing out my old life. Two years ago, on this date, I was quite triumphant. Last year, due to boy drama, I was less sure. This year, I’m a bit sad.
I’m sad, because Ryan’s behavior as late has reminded me WHY we are exes.
I used to pray Ryan would start hitting me, so I had a concrete reason to leave. That’s fucked up, right?
I guess it makes me sad, because of all the good we used to have, and all the good we didn’t have once it ended. We broke each other. You know the Kelly Clarkson song “Because of You”? It could apply to what we did to each other.
He’s recovered. He has a girlfriend he will probably marry. I hope I’ve recovered.
I need to remember these things, because for whatever glorification I developed this past summer of Ryan and I, and for whatever stupid crush I developed this summer, I HAVE to remember how suffocated I felt, and how I needed to get out, and I have to not be sorry for it.
For me. I can’t be sorry for saving myself, because that is exactly what I was doing. So why am I even thinking of it?