So, as I have done two previous times in my life, I asked when I was pretty sure of the answer. I had put off asking, because I was both pretty sure of the answer and unwilling to disturb the status quo. Because I kind of like having a roommate who treats me like a princess.
With HWSNBN, it was supremely complicated by the fact that I had had an epic crush on him for more than a year. When we got together, it was a total high of finally being with the person I wanted to be with, who I had basically given up on him being attainable. Once I ‘had’ him, I wasn’t giving up so easily. I knew he wasn’t treating me properly (this is where I first learned how you should never be with someone who won’t hold your hand in public) but I kept going back. I never carried a cell phone on a regular basis until I started waiting for his phone calls. In retrospect it was a combination of timing, mixed up self-esteem, and mixed up signals. I’ve only talked to him once in the past few years and I feel no ill will or residual feelings for him. It took me a year to disengage though, a year between him telling me he didn’t want to be with me, and me finally leaving. And he only told me about how he didn’t have feelings for me, because I pushed the issue, and I asked. Of course, he was perfectly willing to keep hooking up with me that year. On his terms. And I let it happen.
With OLB, it was more simple, except he made the fatal mistake of telling me “I’m not going to be the guy who falls in love with you.” Which immediately turned on my twisted thought process of “Oh yeah? Watch this.” Even though, on a day to day basis I didn’t even LIKE him that much. The sex was great, but we were also only together on his schedule. By the time I asked the question about his feelings, I really didn’t care about the answer, I just wanted the situation to be done. I was certainly no prize (who wants to date the crazy alcoholic girl?) but he pulled some jackass moves, like making a blatant show of pretending he wasn’t going home with me, and then also when we ‘relapsed’ on hooking up during that disaster of a Chicago trip (really? We’re going to drive out together and share a hotel room? We know exactly what’s going to happen) he spent most of the 13 hour trip back telling me how much I sucked as a person.
So, suffice to say, I have some experience in asking for answers you know, don’t want, but need.
This situation is different, because he’s not a jerk. He’s a really good person. He treats me really well; we’re not hooking up so maybe that has a lot to do with it. He told me in October after our brief foray into drama, that he didn’t have feelings for me. I accepted it. I mostly respected it, other than some incidents. Since the new year, I’d been on my best behavior on that level. And he has been my best friend in DC, the person who supports me when I don’t deserve it, and the person I want to spend the most time with. (Which works out, since we’re um, already roommates. Seperate bedrooms, watch Jeopardy together, get along just fine on a day to day basis roommates). And over the months, my feelings kept evolving, until my therapist finally said to me “You really love him, don’t you?” And it hit me like a ton of bricks and I was like, “Fuck.”
It’s been driving me crazy lately. Because he really stepped up when I needed support in the past couple months and there were a hundred little things that made me think, well maybe…but probably not…but maybe.
And so I finally asked. And he said no. Which I knew he would. For all the ways he has treated me better than other boys have, I knew. I just had to Know.
I have a special gift of being attracted to impossible situations. And I’m strangely okay today; the thing is, he isn’t asking me to make plans to move out (which I also asked if he wanted me to do), and I think once a few days of awkwardness have passed, we’ll be just fine as roommates. I think we can even be friends. And I’m pretty sure if I asked him to walk me home from SMART this Tuesday, he’d say yes, which is another level of mind fuckery, but I have to learn.
Three times. Three boys. Three different situations. One heartbreak, one ‘fuck this noise’, and one yet to be determined. I’m kind of numb today. My mind keeps devolving into third level what-if and maybe scenarios, because my mind tends to live in a perpetual Dawson’s Creek episode when these things happen.
Motorcycle Drive-By just came on the music I have on in the background. I used to listen to this in regards to HWSNBN, especially because of the references to NYC. (“New York City’s evil; the surface is everything/but I could never do that/Someone would see through that/And this is the last time we’ll be friends again/And I’ll get over you, you’ll wonder who I am”). There was this period where I knew I was going to get over HWSNBN and get past it, but that it still hurt. That I reserved the right to listen to sing along with scary relevant lyrics and compose overly analytical dramatic blog entries about it. (…seriously, it’s in the archives). I didn’t do that with OLB, because I didn’t have the feelings for him I had with HWSNBN.
This is its own situation. I’m not saying I’m okay about it now or that I’m not going to have a thousand slips into illogical thinking. But I’m also going to subscribe to the brilliant Jill-IAN theory of thinking, which is “In six months, this isn’t going to hurt like it does now.” She made this revelation, sitting in the Irish Pub across from PLI, and then tossed her hand and said ‘What is it that say Neumsy? When one door closes a window opens?’ With her cavelier Brooklyn accent I couldn’t help but laugh. And six months later, it wasn’t that is didn’t matter anymore, it was that it barely mattered. And then that six months after that, it absolutely didn’t matter.
I have been writing this entry for the past two hours. And I wanted to write it, because maybe the third time is the charm and I will lose my gift for impossible situations. Because as far as impossible situations go, he is an ideal. He is a good person and has treated me very well. I have to remember that “good person” does not immediately equal “good person for me.” And maybe if I can let go of this situation I will find one that is not impossible. Even though that is completely impossible to believe right now.